Lost: Virginia Church Built by Freed Slaves

The 1890 church was too expensive to restore, its pastor says.

Credit: K. Edward Lay

After years of deterioration, a church built for emancipated slaves in Ivy, west of Charlottesville, Va., was demolished last month. An African American land owner donated the site and built the Mount Calvary Baptist Church in 1890 to house a local congregation of recently freed slaves.

The church's style was typical for the countryside, with a rectangular plan and a wood-frame construction. But the men who built the church added several unique features: a wooden hand, pointing to the sky, and wooden silhouettes of African faces with teardrops.

Over the years, the condition of the church had worsened drastically, and its members saved money to build a new church. Pastor Tracie Daniels said the walls of the old church were "bowing out" when she and the church members cleared the building before the demolition.

"It was ready to cave in; we stayed there on prayer," she says.

Freed slaves carved this hand, salvaged before demolition, for the top of the steeple.

Credit: K. Edward Lay

K. Edward Lay, professor emeritus of archaeology at the University of Virginia, documented the Mount Calvary Baptist Church in the 1980s. He describes it as a "very simple and humble building." Its strength lay in the symbolic details, which were like nothing he had seen.

"I definitely think they should have preserved it," Lay says. "It must have been very meaningful to the black population. I would assume that 50 years from now, in retrospect, this will be a big loss for the black community; it was part of their heritage."

According to Pastor Daniels, most people in the community supported the demolition. The building might have been saved 20 years ago if someone had come forward with funding, but Pastor Daniels said it would have cost "a ridiculous amount of money" to preserve the church now. "We could have built two new churches for that money," Pastor Daniels said. "We are a small congregation; we can't afford it."

Tearful faces adorned Mount Calvary Baptist Church in Ivy, Va.

Credit: K. Edward Lay

The silhouette faces were removed from the church years before the demolition, and they will be on display in the new church, which is scheduled to be finished this summer. The same showcase will also feature the original steeple hand, which was replaced by a replica several years ago. If it is possible, Daniels says, the reproduced wooden hand will again be placed at the top of the new bell tower.

The congregation is focusing on the future, Daniels says. "We are looking forward to the new church." 

For more photos, stories, and tips, subscribe to the print edition of Preservation magazine.

Subscribe to the Today's News RSS feed


Submitted by roberta at: July 19, 2009
as a member it is sad to see it go! But where are the who want to save it? Do they have money to help the church out financially! The church is old I am 46 so they tell you about how long it has been there

Submitted by Preservation Piedmont at: February 12, 2009
This church was also documented and photographed by Eryn Brennan, Justin Sarafin, and Brian Broadus, board members of Preservation Piedmont based in Charlottesville, Virginia, with the assistance of Edward Chappell, Director of Architectural Research, Colonial Williamsburg. For more information, please contact preservationpiedmont@gmail.com.

Submitted by Steve Lindsey at: February 6, 2009
This breaks my heart...