Montana Street Loses Two Historic Buildings
By Jesse Aber | Online Only | Feb. 2, 2008
The Bishop Gilmore School is being demolished because its owner, the Cathedral of Helena, lacked the money to maintain it.
Credit: Jesse Aber
Feb. 2, 2008
Dear Preservation 911,
In Helena, Mont., two historic structures are disappearing from the landscape. This month, both the Shober House and the Bishop Gilmore School, a huge Greek revival building, are now coming down. The Shober House will live to see another day; its owner is moving the 1885 house.
The salvors have taken down the massive dentilated pediment from Bishop Gilmore. The building's huge, 45-foot-tall columns are now being dismantled, capitals first. The story here is demolition by neglect, although the owner, the Cathedral of Helena, did comply with the city's ordinance that the structure had to sit for a year before coming down to provide a last chance for an adaptive re-use or some other solution.
Across the street, Scott Nelson and his contractor are dismantling windows before sectioning the Shober House to move in sections to his new home site. It will be something to see the brick walls make the move without coming down.
This neighborhood will look strange without these two prominent historic buildings on their original sites.
There were no alternatives feasible for saving the school for adaptive reuse because of asbestos issues and lack of funding. I had heard several years ago that the Cathedral had wanted more parking, which, ironically, was the biggest reason the Methodist St Paul's across the street wanted to demolish the Shober House.
A friend that was watching the demolition and is a member of the St. Helena Cathedral congregation told me that vandalism and teens entering the old school to party and carry on was such a liability that the church had to go forward on demolition. My friend had proposed using the columns for a memorial on the south side of the Cathedral, but that idea was abandoned as the columns were "too large for the memorial site." I guess the salvage company gets the spoils: columns and capitals, etc.
Sincerely,
Jesse Aber
E-mail the writer with advice, comments, or commiseration.
Got a 911 in your town? Send us an e-mail.
Preservation 911 is a message board open to all readers. While National Trust staff will respond to the extent feasible, this will not be possible in all cases. We encourage other readers involved in state or local preservation to respond with advice or assistance. To contact either a regional office of the National Trust, a statewide or local nonprofit organization, or your state's historic preservation office, click here for a state-by-state list.
The National Trust's regional and field offices bring the programs and tools of the Trust to communities across the country. They offer technical assistance through consultations and field visits and financial help through small grants. They hold educational programs for professional preservationists and work to foster policies that help historic places. They also provide leadership on issues that concern entire regions, such as saving historic schools, fighting sprawl, and revitalizing cities.
Comments
