Madison Historical Society

Why the Old Tavern Matters:

Here in Northeast Ohio we are on the verge of losing a historic treasure: The Old Tavern in Unionville.  Once a busy establishment known for it's unique cuisine, inviting atmosphere and rich history now stands empty, un-kept and falling apart.  Situated on the Northwest corner of the main intersection of this small town it stands as a bleak reminder of its glory days.

At one time it was the only destination in the area for travelers through this part of the Connecticut Western Reserve.  Over it's two hundred plus years in existence it has provided many visitors with food, spirits, entertainment, lodging and was for a short time the last stop on the Underground Railroad before fleeing slaves were taken to the docks at Ellensburg, now Madison, to take them across Lake Erie to freedom in Canada.

Through out its years in operation, it has had such influential guests as Thomas Edison, Henry Ford and even Harriet Beecher Stowe while she conducted research for her runaway slave novel, "Uncle Tom's Cabin". 

The building and grounds have changed owners several times since it's humble beginnings as a log cabin, known as the Webster House, built in 1798.  At that time it was operated as stop for stagecoaches traveling between Buffalo, New York and Cleveland, Ohio.  Over time, and with each new owner, renovations and updates have been made to make the building what it is today. 

What always remained constant over its two hundred year span was the dedication to providing locals and travelers both near and far with food and comfort.  The Old Tavern has been used by many generations as a gathering place to celebrate life events such as weddings, anniversaries, birthdays, local celebrations, and the everyday meal with a friend.  Until recently guests were able to use the restaurant, many gathering rooms, a second floor ballroom, as well as take a tour of the upstairs boarding rooms and basement
where remnants of the original log cabin and tunnels from the Underground Railroad are still visible today.

An establishment as deeply rooted in our community and national history as The Old Tavern is, should be appreciated.  A place for friends and family to gather together to celebrate, a place where history meets present day, a place to learn about our past and the significance of our ancestors actions to bring about change.  A building that has seen more in its lifetime than anyone alive today is a testament to our community's dedication to our heritage.

However, as it stands now, The Old Tavern has faded into the 21st century as just another vacant building, a forgotten memory.  If we lost The Old Tavern we would lose that connection to our past that made us the community we are today.  It is our hope that The Old Tavern will once again be open.  Operating as restaurant, banquet hall, dinner theater, or museum so that future generations will be able to enjoy it for many years to come.

The information provided on Community Challenge pages is provided "as is," and the National Trust for Historic Preservation does not make any representations, endorsements, or warranties (either expressed or implied) on any comments, reviews, or suggestions posted. Neither does the National Trust assume responsibility or liability for the same.